Allison Harbin, PhD

writer, researcher, and editor

  • Writing
  • Newsletter
  • post-phd the blog
  • Writing Portfolio
    • Interviews
    • Essays
    • Narativ Case Story Onboarding
  • Editing Services
  • contact
Quit lit that's never been more terrifying by Allison Harbin Post-PhD

Adjuncting (and the Academic Job Market)

June 07, 2017 by Allison Harbin in Systemic Problems In Ed
Post-PhD post cover image Adjuncting (and the Academic Job Market)

Adjuncting (and the Academic Job Market)

In this post: A cold dose of reality demonstrating academias failure to be the meritocracy we all thought it was.

Next week: Job opportunities for PhD students from someone who has obsessively researched her own options after leaving academia.

Last week: I discuss the difficulty of leaving academia and the importance of strategic thinking and embracing the unknown when it comes to next step career moves.

According to the American Association of University Professors, today more than 50% of all faculty appointments are part-time.

Adjuncts constitute 76.4% of U.S. faculty. Let that sink in. For those of us used to grading: that's barely a passing grade. That means that tenured faculty comprise only 23.6% of the instructional labor force. 

Read the full article here

So, for those of us who want a tenure-track job, that means we are not only competing with our fellow adjuncts and graduate students, but also with tenured professors looking to switch institutions. The job competition pool is so small that in a very real way, new Ph.D.s could (and at times, are) competing with their advisors for positions.

Tip or donate to Post PhD or Not Safe for School a simple, meaningful way to support this work: tip the author :)
Donate

 Imagine emailing your advisor to ask for a recommendation letter for a job for which you are a perfect fit. Imagine your advisor, who is in the same field as you, responding: "I'd be happy to write you a rec letter, but I want to let you know that I'm applying for the same job." This actually happened. When my friend told me this had happened to her, I wondered what the point of even asking for a rec letter from her advisor even was-- would her advisor actually write a complimentary letter, knowing that she too was applying for the same job? What does this say about the job market itself? What real chance does a recent PhD have if they are competing with a tenured professor, with a book and many  peer reviewed articles and nearly a decade of teaching?

By the way, neither of them ended up getting the job. 

Going back to the numbers, let's assume that 23.6% of the academic jobs out there are actually tenure-track (that statistic speaks to the amount of tenured professors currently employed, not the percentage of job listings, just so you know)

Ok, if 23.6% of jobs out there are tenure-track, everyone is applying to them. Who is getting them? According to this article by Gawker, almost 90% of those jobs go to Ivy leaguers. Here's another excellent article by Slate detailing this horrifying reality. 

Further, the number of academic positions continues to drop each year. That means every year on the job market your chances of securing a job drop. Here's an excellent article by Chronicle Vitae about Academy's 1%

My question is: as Ph.D.s, we are trained to question everything, to research, to write with conviction, and to work incredibly hard. Aren't we too smart to fall for this?

-Allison Harbin

Not Safe for School Newsletter cover banner: an irreverent weekly newsletter about racism, corruption, and education

Other posts on this topic:

Featured
Discussion Guide: Academia, Love, and Madness
Feb 23, 2022
Discussion Guide: Academia, Love, and Madness
Feb 23, 2022

In this post: A reflection on the UCU strikes, past and upcoming content, and what the f*ck we are supposed to do with all this mess, including a list of what I'm reading.

Feb 23, 2022
Answers for your anonymously asked questions, alt-ac career advice edition
Jan 21, 2022
Answers for your anonymously asked questions, alt-ac career advice edition
Jan 21, 2022

In this post: I talk about career transitions from academia to beyond and having to realign your identity, values, and process.

Jan 21, 2022
Discussion Guide to January 28th's Fireside Chat: How to Transgress the University
Jan 17, 2022
Discussion Guide to January 28th's Fireside Chat: How to Transgress the University
Jan 17, 2022

In this post: I am posing the most common concerns this month to an impressive cast of alt-academics, current professors, post-docs, and graduate students to join Post-PhD in a live fireside chat.

Jan 17, 2022
6.png
Jan 11, 2022
Resources for the Resistance: Radical Pedagogy & Early Critiques of Higher Education
Jan 11, 2022

In this post: This January's reading list, a fully annotated bibliography including racial pedagogy and foundational critiques of higher education.

Jan 11, 2022
Towards the Undercommons: Reimagining the Role of the Intellectual
Dec 31, 2021
Towards the Undercommons: Reimagining the Role of the Intellectual
Dec 31, 2021

In this post: I pose a discourse about the adjunct crisis, and the larger systemic educational crisis we are currently in, and ponder on the differences our generation of thinkers can make for the next.

Dec 31, 2021
Letters to a Young Scholar: A Bill of Rights for Early Graduate Students
Dec 3, 2021
Letters to a Young Scholar: A Bill of Rights for Early Graduate Students
Dec 3, 2021

In this post: As Fred Moten and Stefano Harney make clear: the only ethical relationship to the university today is a criminal one.

Dec 3, 2021
Advice for Overachievers with Dr. Caitlin Faas
Sep 7, 2021
Advice for Overachievers with Dr. Caitlin Faas
Sep 7, 2021

In this post: Dr. Caitlin Faas and I go over wtf it means to be both "embodied" and "reduce stress," and how to know your limits while staying productive.

Sep 7, 2021
I can't get no (intellectual) satisfaction
Feb 10, 2021
I can't get no (intellectual) satisfaction
Feb 10, 2021

In this post: I write about the satisfaction beyond academia, and how to continue to embody the principles ad methods you honed in academia in the real world.

Feb 10, 2021
On Leaving Academia and Failing (over and over)
Jan 27, 2021
On Leaving Academia and Failing (over and over)
Jan 27, 2021

In this post: I get real about the jobs I tried to get in my transition to alt-ac and Post-PhD. Let's talk about the jobs I tried to get, how little I was paid, ad what I learned from that experience.

Jan 27, 2021
It's Better in Europe: My Plenary Talk at the Reward Equator Conference
Jul 13, 2020
It's Better in Europe: My Plenary Talk at the Reward Equator Conference
Jul 13, 2020

In this post: I cover my plenary talk at the Reward Equator Conference in Berlin. I also include an amazing collection of engaged scholars I've found who are dedicated to supporting Ph.D. researchers.

Jul 13, 2020
Educating for the Resistance
Mar 27, 2019
Educating for the Resistance
Mar 27, 2019

In this post: For the love of pedagogy, I discuss my role as a professor and a teacher in NYC, and how there is zero incentive for educators to care about their students.

Mar 27, 2019
Academics Anonymous: Hi, My Name is ____ and I'm an Academic
Feb 6, 2019
Academics Anonymous: Hi, My Name is ____ and I'm an Academic
Feb 6, 2019

In this post: It's been eighteen months since I left academia, here's what I learned in my recovery.

Feb 6, 2019
When PhDs tackle the Business World
Sep 12, 2018
When PhDs tackle the Business World
Sep 12, 2018

In this post: I talk about my dissociation from the legal drama I was put through, and what it teaches me when it rears its ugly head.

Sep 12, 2018
It Gets Better: Ph.D. to Freelance Writer
Aug 8, 2018
It Gets Better: Ph.D. to Freelance Writer
Aug 8, 2018

In this post: I talk about the gradual growth of my editing and writing client base and the happiness I've found in learning the ropes of business writing, web copy, and content writing.

Aug 8, 2018
June 07, 2017 /Allison Harbin
higher eduation, is academia exploitative, adjunct professor, professor salary, adjunct crisis, new faculty majority, academic job market, neoliberal university
Systemic Problems In Ed
  • Newer
  • Older